Context
The picture is from Calatrava impicati and is under an attribution - non commercial - share alike Creative Commons license.
This is about a real-life divide: Venice (Italy) has a new-fangled bridge by controversial architect Calatrava, who also committed other bridges, in Dallas for instance. See Spanish Fly - Dallas turns rape to romance with Calatrava bridges by Jim Schutze, Dallas Observer,December 18, 2003:
...The proposed Calatrava bridge or bridges in Dallas will be, after all, suspension bridges over a freeway and a narrow drainage ditch. Their true nature, in architectural terms, will be as follies. An architectural folly, according to the Shorter Oxford English Dictionary, is "any costly structure considered to have shown folly in the builder." The mental state of folly is defined by the OED as "the quality or state of being foolish, want of good sense, weakness or derangement of mind." That about nails it. ...
And so Venice is going to have its own Calatrava's - or rather Mayor Cacciari's - folly too.
The bridge was meant to be very solemnly inaugurated on Sept. 18, 2008, with the President of the Italian Republic attending. However, this ceremony was cancelled due to the protests of associations of people with disabilities, in particular of the Un ponte per tutti petition, because the bridge violates national accessibility norms, as it includes glass-covered stairs that exclude people in wheelchairs.
In a way, the petition has reached its goal: there won't be a solemn inauguration on Sept. 18. However, Mayor Cacciari, while recognizing the "errors" made in choosing that bridge, has also heaped insults on the associations of people with disabilities for having prevented the ceremony, arrogantly claiming that he hasn't even listened to them ("le associazioni che hanno protestato non le ho nemmeno sentite" - Il Gazzettino di Venezia, quoted in Calatrava: ponte Potëmkin? by Roberto Scano, Aug. 28, 2008).
One way to help Mayor Cacciari understand that his explicit contempt for people with disabilities is not alright might be to go on signing the Un ponte per tutti petition, adding comments. Hence the translation below.
For more information on the issue, see the links collected under the Cacciari_accessibilità tag on del.icio.us.
Translation of the petition
From: firmiamo.it/unpontepertutti:
This petition aims at making public administrations sensitive to the respect of norms in force concerning architectural obstacles. Concretely,this petition is about Calatrava's bridge in Venice, the fourth bridge on the Canal Grande due to be inaugurated on September 18, 2008, in the presence of the President of the [Italian] Republic.
With this petition we request that the official inauguration (in the presence of the President) be postponed until the auxiliary means (the so-called "ovovia" [1] inorder to enable people with disabilities to cross the bridge like everybody, i.e. to be able, like all citizens, to use this alternative solution to public transportation (for the journey from the train station to Piazzale Roma, a tourist pays Euro 6.50].
We therefore request from:
- the Mayor of Venice, Prof. Massimo Cacciari
- the President of the Republic, Giorgio Napolitano
that they postpone the official inauguration in the presence of the President of the Republic until the work is actually usable by all citizens.
This petition does not intend to prevent the opening of the bridge for the citizens, but to only enhance its inauguration when it will actually be accessible (as foreseen, morover, by the norms in force).
[1] "egg-way" - pictures of the project in Ponte di Calatrava, costruito il telaio della cabina dell'ovovia (problems: the "ovovia" crossing will take 17 minutes), and technical problems are delaying its inauguration to an unconfirmed date [N. of T].








© 2007-8